Most growing businesses reach the same point. The phone system feels outdated. The servers are aging. The copier lease is nearing renewal. Everything seems due for an upgrade at the same time.
Budgets rarely allow all three to be replaced at once.
So leadership asks a practical question. What office technology should we replace first: phones, IT infrastructure, or copiers?
The answer is not based on preference. It is based on risk, operational impact, and long-term cost.
Step One: Identify Which System Creates the Most Risk
Not all technology carries equal risk when it fails.
If a copier goes down, productivity slows. If the IT infrastructure fails, operations may stop entirely. If the phone system drops calls, revenue and customer trust are affected.
The first replacement priority should usually be the system that creates the highest business risk.
Ask:
• Which system would stop operations completely if it failed?
• Which system exposes us to security risk?
• Which system affects customers directly?
• Which system would cost the most during downtime?
The answers usually make priorities clearer.
When IT Infrastructure Should Be Replaced First
IT infrastructure often carries the highest risk.
This includes:
• Servers
• Firewalls
• Network switches
• Backup systems
• Core applications
If infrastructure is aging, unsupported, or experiencing recurring outages, it should usually be the first priority for replacement.
Security Risk Is the Deciding Factor
Unsupported operating systems and outdated firewalls create security gaps. Cyber incidents cost far more than planned upgrades.
According to the National Institute of Standards and Technology, unsupported systems significantly increase exposure to cyber threats.
If your IT environment lacks current security protections, replacing infrastructure should move to the top of the list.
Downtime Costs Add Up Quickly
When infrastructure fails:
• Employees cannot access systems
• Cloud tools disconnect
• Email stops functioning
• File sharing becomes unavailable
Downtime costs multiply across the entire organization.
If infrastructure instability is affecting productivity, it should be addressed before phones or copiers are affected.
When Phones Should Be Replaced First
Phone systems affect customer communication directly.
• Calls are dropping frequently
• Audio quality is poor
• Support is unreliable
• The system lacks mobile capability
• Billing has become unpredictable
Revenue Impact Matters
If your business depends heavily on inbound or outbound calls, phone performance directly affects revenue.
Missed calls mean missed opportunities. Poor call quality reduces professionalism. In sales-driven or service-driven businesses, phones may take priority over copiers or even some infrastructure upgrades.
Scalability Concerns
If your phone system cannot support remote workers, additional locations, or growth, replacement may be necessary sooner rather than later.
Modern VoIP systems scale more easily and integrate with collaboration tools. If growth is constrained by phone limitations, upgrading phones can support expansion.
When Copiers Should Be Replaced First
Copiers typically carry lower operational risk than IT or phone systems. However, they can still create financial and workflow issues.
Consider replacing copiers first if:
• Lease costs have spiked unexpectedly
• Overage charges are recurring
• Devices are frequently down
• Print security is outdated
• The fleet is misaligned with usage
Cost Control Opportunities
Sometimes, copiers present the easiest cost optimization opportunity. Adjusting print contracts or replacing misaligned devices may reduce operational expenses quickly.
If copier inefficiency is draining the budget without improving productivity, addressing print first can create room to upgrade other systems.
How to Evaluate Business Impact Objectivel
Instead of relying on frustration levels, evaluate systems across four categories:
• Risk exposure
• Downtime frequency
• Customer impact
• Financial cost
Score each system honestly. The system with the highest combined risk and cost impact should move first.
Hidden Costs of Delaying IT Replacement
If infrastructure is aging but still functioning, leaders often postpone upgrades.
Hidden costs include:
• Increased security exposure
• Higher maintenance expenses
• Slower performance
• Employee frustration
• Emergency replacement premiums
Infrastructure delays usually compound long-term costs.
Hidden Costs of Delaying Phone Replacement
Outdated phone systems may lead to:
• Customer dissatisfaction
• Reduced call visibility
• Missed remote flexibility
• Ongoing support frustration
The cost is often revenue-related rather than operational.
Hidden Costs of Delaying Copier Replacement
Copiers rarely shut down an organization, but they create operational friction.
Delays may cause:
• Increased service calls
• Higher per-page costs
• Security gaps in document handling
• Workflow inefficiencies
While serious, these impacts are usually narrower than IT infrastructure failures.
Replacement Strategy: Sequence Instead of Simultaneous
Most businesses benefit from sequencing upgrades rather than replacing everything at once.
A common order looks like this:
Stabilize and secure the IT infrastructure
Upgrade phone systems for communication efficiency
Optimize copier fleet for cost control
This sequence reduces risk first, improves communication second, and refines operational cost third.
Each business may differ, but risk and security usually come first.
When a Combined Upgrade Makes Sense
Sometimes systems overlap.
Examples include:
• Replacing network infrastructure alongside VoIP
• Upgrading print security during IT modernization
• Aligning copier network segmentation with firewall updates
Bundling related upgrades reduces disruption and improves efficiency.
Budgeting Considerations
Technology replacement should align with financial planning.
Instead of reactive upgrades, create a roadmap that:
• Documents system age
• Tracks support expiration dates
• Plans refresh cycles
• Aligns upgrades with growth
Proactive planning avoids stacking replacements into a single expensive year.
How Managed IT and Technology Partners Help Prioritize
Choosing what to replace first becomes easier with visibility.
A structured technology assessment evaluates:
• Infrastructure health
• Security posture
• Phone performance metrics
• Print usage data
• Lifecycle status
AIS works with businesses across Las Vegas and Southern California to create prioritized technology roadmaps that reduce risk and support growth.
The goal is clarity, not upselling.
What the Right Decision Should Feel Like
The right replacement decision reduces anxiety. Systems become more stable. Costs become predictable. Employees notice fewer interruptions. Leadership spends less time managing technology problems.
When upgrades are prioritized correctly, technology supports the business instead of distracting from it.
Next Steps: Build a Technology Replacement Plan
If you are unsure whether to replace phones, IT infrastructure, or copiers first, AIS offers a Technology Priority Assessment. This review evaluates risk, cost, and operational impact to determine the right sequence for your business.
Topics:
